If you have narrowed down your search to the Saatva and Puffy mattresses, you’re in good shape. They are both quality mattresses.
Still, how do you make the final decision between the Saatva mattress and Puffy mattress? Fear not. I’m here to help.
Check out our full written comparison with hi-res photos and detailed notes here:
We maintain an affiliate relationship with some of the products reviewed, which means we get a percentage of a sale if you click over from our site (at no cost to our readers). See our full disclaimer and disclosures here:
Besides the fact that these are similarly priced, popular mattresses, they are really quite different.
First, the Saatva is an innerspring mattress, while the Puffy is a memory foam mattress. Because of this, they have different feels.
The Saatva has a traditional innerspring feel where you sleep on top of the mattress. The Puffy has a classic memory foam feel where you sleep “in” the mattress.
The Saatva is also a taller mattress and a firmer mattress.
If you have enjoyed sleeping on luxury hotel mattresses, the Saatva could be a good choice. It has a soft pillow-top over two layers of coils, so if you have had success on this type of mattress, the Saatva should work for you.
Also, if you need a back sleeper mattress or stomach sleeping mattress, the Saatva should be the way to go. The dual layers of coils should offer better support than the Puffy mattress. When you are on your back, most people should find that their hips sink into the pillow-top just the right amount while the rest of their body is properly supported. While stomach sleeping, you shouldn’t feel yourself bowing into the mattress.
Are you a larger person? You might want to pick the Saatva innerspring mattress. Again, it is the more supportive mattress, so heavier-weight sleepers have less chance of “bottoming out” on the mattress. On the Puffy, heavier people might press through the soft comfort layer and engage the support layer beneath.
However, if you are a light- or average-weight person, the Puffy could be a good side sleeper mattress. You should sink into the soft comfort layer and feel little pressure on your shoulders and hips.
Also, if you are a fan of memory foam mattresses, the Puffy is a clear choice. It has that soft, sinking quality. So if you like classic memory foam, go with the Puffy.
The memory foam layer also makes the Puffy a better mattress for couples. This layer cuts down on motion transfer, so you should feel less of your partner’s movements on the Puffy.
If you consider these details, your choice should be simple!